At Vanderbilt University’s Owen Graduate School of Management, one-quarter of the Nashville, Tenn., school’s 2011 M.B.A. class was international, with a number of students from China, India and South Korea . “If we have too high a [percentage] of international students and then we can’t place them, shame on us,” says Tami Fassinger, chief recruiting officer at the school. This WSJ story, http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304072004577323861675549408.html, highlights the difficulty career service offices at business schools are having in placing their international students. Having lived through some very difficult years in my former work in career services at the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies, I empathize with the career staffs cited in this story.
As this piece begins: Graduate business schools, eager to enhance their global image and offset declining demand at home, are attracting international students—and that is causing headaches for the career-services offices….Is this a surprise to any institution that aggressively recruits international students? Perhaps there is an absence of overall strategic planning which examines the capacity of the institution’s student services to meet the demands of a growing population of international students. And the burden surely falls upon career services when it comes to building linkages to the marketplace which open doors for these students.
This is a succinct and well written IIE briefing paper – http://www.iie.org/en/Research-and-Publications/Publications-and-Reports/IIE-Bookstore/~/media/Files/Corporate/Publications/Valuing%20Study%20Abroad.ashx – from a conference where the British Academy and the University Council of Modern Languages (UCML) released a joint position statement, Valuing the Year Abroad, that advocated support for funding a third year abroad for British undergraduate students and drew on case studies from a survey they conducted among study abroad alumni. With representatives from the United States, China, and Germany, the international panel was invited to discuss British government and higher education policy on study abroad, and other countries’ policies and best practices in study abroad.
The University of Rhode Island’s five-year program that grants students a BS in engineering and a BA in a foreign language. was cited as a best practice model. In the fourth year of the program, students go abroad to study engineering in the foreign language (German, French, Spanish, or Chinese) of the host country university, and then do a hands-on internship with a company in the host country (for example, one URI student in Germany took engineering classes in German and held an engineering internship at BMW).
This is a topic which has been around for a long time; it has surfaced as a hot issue in terms of the impact of the recession on state economic development. And this in turn has led to a discussion about the linkage between college majors and entry into the workforce after graduation. Wake Forest is holding an interesting conference this week on “Rethinking success” and their site has a great list of readings: http://rethinkingsuccess.wfu.edu/resources
I’ve been meaning to comment on this Chronicle article: http://chronicle.com/article/In-China-as-Job-Possibilities/131127/. I thought it was difficult enough to work with 500 students at Hopkins-SAIS career services; now we see an awakening of a new career path for Chinese higher ed professionals in the career counseling field! Of course, they are having to deal with finding employment for 6.3 million college grads!
Actually, the campus offices are referred to as “employment-guidance” centers. The case study in this article describes the canter at Nankai University in Tianjin. While the typical Western career services office employs a variety of coaching tools and a variety of service-delivery models, Nankai relies preponderantly on web-based tools. In the last 4 months of 2011, the web site posted 30,000 job ads from 2,600 employers!
According to the HR director of a major staffing agency, Fesco, students “have no conception of what a job or a career means.” This points to the legacy of “job allocation” rooted in the Communist system’s practices. The idea of freedom of choice based upon assessment of student career aspirations may be a goal in the evolving profession of employment counseling, but, it’s a long term one.
The Global Talent Retention Initiative [GTRI] http://detroit.cbslocal.com/2012/03/21/colleges-international-students-key-to-michigans-economic-growth/#.T3NFXtZ_zVk.email of Southeast Michigan is a wonderful model pointing to the convergence of interests among educators, academic institutions, and industry –all working together towards the economic revitalization of the state. And it illustrates the critical contribution of international students whose career choices and areas of study are highly correlated with job opportunities in the marketplace.
The GTRI is a joint effort of Michigan State University, the University of Michigan and Wayne State University. The program director states, “So we’re launching an aggressive new effort to help Michigan-based companies fill jobs in the STEM fields with talented engineers from overseas. We think this effort will pay for itself immediately because these employers will have the talent they need to win new contracts and immediately contribute to the Michigan tax base with improved profits and income tax generation.” Fast-paced economic growth in the health care, computer and engineering sectors, coupled with a shortage of domestic students graduating with degrees in the high-demand science, technology, engineering and math fields, has created a significant percentage of jobs in Michigan that employers are unable to fill, threatening further economic growth and their ability to compete.
“The fact that there just aren’t enough American-born students earning degrees in the STEM fields means that there is a significant mismatch between degrees granted and available jobs. Programs such as GTRI’s are critically important for connecting businesses with the talent they need to grow and remain globally competitive.”
The GTRI is a product of the Global Detroit Study about the impact of immigrant talent on the region’s economy. In collaboration with seven partner universities, the American Immigration Lawyers Association, Michigan’s economic development agencies, and ethnic chambers and organizations in Southeast Michigan, GTRI provides international students and local employers with training and resources on relevant immigration regulations, finding a job and working in the Detroit area, and many cross-cultural issues that both employers and international applicants may experience during the hiring process.
I was struck by this NY Times op-ed and its focus on a topic not usually reported on in mainstream media –the difficulty of adjusting to life in our globalized economic marketplace: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/22/opinion/many-still-live-with-homesickness.html?_r=1&emc=eta1
“ACCORDING to a recent Gallup World Poll, 1.1 billion people, or one-quarter of the earth’s adults, want to move temporarily to another country in the hope of finding more profitable work. An additional 630 million people would like to move abroad permanently.” This number might or might not include the 3.3 million students studying outside their home country. Those of us working on college campuses have direct contact with students, scholars and researchers from around the world – but no matter what purpose one has for leaving one’s home country, it is not an easy transition and often comes with a lot of deeply felt emotional baggage.
The world is flatter, but, this does exacerbate the impact of the transitions we make as we move around the planet. As the writer says, “Technology also seduces us into thinking that migration is painless.”
Reporting on IFC conference on private education, “Making Global Connections,” University World News http://test.universityworldnews.com/article.php?story=2012031514592545 offers glimpse of growing efforts to bridge employer needs for talent with innovative private sector education initiatives.
The article states: Some “30% of employers globally say they do not find enough people for the jobs that they have,” Gassan Al-Kibsi, managing partner at McKinsey and Company in Saudi Arabia, told the IFC’s conference on private education held in Dubai from 6-8 March. Top-up courses for graduates, devised with industry in mind, can bridge the gap between academic courses and working life. Such courses are organised to supplement university degrees and are often provided by private or non-profit institutions. “Government institutions are often unable to understand employers’ needs,” Al-Kibsi said.
The International Finance Corporation (IFC) has built an investment portfolio of US$400 million involving 69 projects in 33 countries, many of them in higher education. “Like it or not, the private sector will increasingly be part of the solution in offering skills to young people all over the world,” said Guy Ellena, the IFC’s Istanbul-based regional director of manufacturing, agribusiness and services for Europe, the Middle East and North Africa. “We really believe there is a major role for the private sector to complement public education,” he told University World News.
To understand the changing role – and new funding priority – of the IFC with regard to private sector support in the education sector, go to http://www.universityworldnews.com/article.php?story=20120224110837965
This recent post to University World News caught my attention: At the University of Rhode Island, their International Engineering Program [IEP] is designed to fully integrate international experience with their course of study. “The IEP’s model, unchanged since its inception 25 years ago, is that of a five-year dual bachelor programme in which students complete a language major alongside the usual engineering curriculum requirements. In order to reinforce nascent language skills, students embark on synchronous study of and work in both disciplines in a country of their choice during the fourth year. The first six months of study at the partner university are followed by a paid internship at an affiliated company for the remainder of the year.”
Books
“Employer Perspectives on International Education,” in SAGE Handbook on International Higher Education, SAGE publications, 2012
AIFS Student Guide to Study Abroad and Career Development, American Institute for Foreign Study, Stamford, CT, 2011
Diversity in International Education: Hands-On Workshop Summary Report, American Institute for Foreign Study Foundation, 2010
Cooperating With a University in the United States: NAFSA’s Guide to Interuniversity Linkages, Editor, NAFSA: Association of International Educators, revised, 2007
Impact of Education Abroad on Career Development, Volumes I/II, American Institute for Foreign Study, Stamford, CT, 2005
The Role of Student Affairs and Services in Higher Education (contributing writer on career services) UNESCO, Paris, France, 2002
Study Abroad: A 21st Century Perspective: Volume II, The Changing Landscape, Editor, American Institute for Foreign Study Foundation, Stamford, CT, 2002
Study Abroad: A 21st Century Perspective, Editor, American Institute for Foreign Study Foundation, Stamford, CT, 2001
Service-Learning: A Movement’s Pioneers Reflect on Its Origins, Practice and Future, Jossey-Bass, 1999 [cited as a leading pioneer in this oral history project]
Cooperating With a University in the U.S.A.: NAFSA’s Guide to Interuniversity Linkages, NAFSA: Association of International Educators, with Thullen, Homer, and Carty, 1997
“Effective Support Services to International Students,” in Developing International Education Programs, Jossey Bass, New Directions for Community Colleges #70, 1990
“The Lisle Fellowship: A Case Study,” in Cross Cultural Learning, Jossey Bass, New Directions for Experiential Learning #11, 1981
Articles
“The Right Tool for the Job,” International Educator, NAFSA: Association of International Educators, summer, 2005
” Life Begins at Fifty: A Brief History of NAFSA and its Members,” International Educator, NAFSA: Association of International Educators, October/November, 1998
“How Do we Feel About Foreign Aid?”, International Educator, NAFSA: Association of International Educators, Winter, 1995
“Third World Focus, ” Quarterly column, Transitions Abroad: The Guide to Learning, Living, and Working Overseas, 1986 1992
“Third World Service Learning Programs,” American Institute for Foreign Study, Study Abroad Advisors Series #4, 1989
“Principles of Experiential Cross Cultural Learning,” Experiential Education,. National Society for Internships and Experiential Education, 1982
“Non Formal Education and Rural Development: An Historical Sketch and Selected Case Studies,” Journal of New Frontiers in Education, New Delhi, November, 1975
Book Reviews [in NAFSA International Educator]
“The Global Student Experience: An International and Comparative Perspective,” Kandidko & Weyers, ed., 2013
“Student Learning Abroad: what Our Students Are Learning, what They’re Not, and What We Can Do About It,” Vende Berg, Paige & Lou, 2013
“International Students and Global Mobility in Higher Education: National Trends and New Directions,” Bhandari & Blumenthal, 2012
“Integrating Study Abroad into the Curriculum,” Elizabeth Brewer and Kiran Cunningham, 2012
“The SAGE Handbook on Intercultural Competence,” Darla Deardorff, editor, 2011
“International India: A Turning Point in Educational Exchange with the U.S.,” Rajika Bhandari, editor, 2011
“The First-Time Effect: The Impact of Study Abroad on College Student Intellectual Development,” Joshua S. McKeown, 2010
“Intercultural Competence: Intercultural Communications Across Cultures,” 5th edition, Myron W. Lustig and Jolene Koester, 2009
“Working World: Careers in International Education, Exchange and Development,” Sherry L. Mueller & Mark Overmann, 2009
“A Handbook for Counseling International Students in the United States,” Hemla D. Singaravelu and Mark Pope, 2008
“Handbook for Hosting: The Academy for Educational Development Guide to Welcoming U.S. Students To Your Campus,” 2007
“Knowing and Doing: The Theory and Practice of Service-Learning,” Linda Chisholm, editor, 2006
“The First Resort of Kings,” Richard T. Arndt , 2006
“The Big Guide to Living and Working Overseas,” Jean-Marc Hachey, 4th edition, 2005
“Global Citizen: A Guide to Creating an International Life and Career for Students, Professionals, Retirees and Families,” Elizabeth Kruempelmann, 2002
“Beyond Borders: How International Developments are Changing Student Affairs Practice,” New Directions in Student Services, 2001
“The Expanding Role of State & Local Governments in U.S. Foreign Affairs,” Earl H. Fry, 1998
“Birth of a New World: An Open Moment for International Leadership,” Harlan Cleveland, 1993
I’m very interested in efforts to link career training with community-based organizations, industry and community colleges. I believe the Obama administration is making an important contribution in its focus on community colleges for this reason. These two stories describe creative approaches to closing the skills gap for low income and minority communities in PA and MN:
In PA, the Highmark company is providing $2 million in funding to 25 organizations across the state for career development and job training through the Highmark Local Workforce Initiative. The initiative was created to recognize organizations that demonstrate the proven ability to make an impact in diverse rural and urban neighborhoods where there may be minority populations, individuals with a disability, veterans or displaced workers seeking career opportunities and advancements.
In MN, VISTA has built a partnership with the Women’s Fund and Presenting Yourself for first-generation college women to enable Central Lakes College to equip its students with the tools necessary to build successful futures. Local AmeriCorps VISTAs are sponsored and supported by the Initiative Foundation, based in Little Falls, in partnership with the Corporation for National and Community Service which coordinates AmeriCorps VISTA, AmeriCorps NCCC (National Civilian Community Corps), AmeriCorps State and National and Senior Corps.